People Pleasing

Mr. Nice Guy: Therapy for People Pleasing

A hand holding three colorful flowers through a wooden fence.

The "Mr. Nice Guy" syndrome affects countless men who prioritize others' needs above their own. While kindness is admirable, chronic people-pleasing creates a damaging cycle of self-sacrifice, leading to burnout and disconnection from one’s own needs. This pattern often stems from deeply rooted beliefs that a man's worth is measured by how much he does for others or that keeping everyone happy ensures acceptance and avoids conflict.

How People-Pleasing Shows Up in Men's Lives

For men caught in this cycle, life becomes a series of reluctant "yes" responses and suppressed needs. You might find yourself agreeing to help a neighbor move furniture on your only day off, taking on extra work projects despite being overwhelmed, or avoiding necessary conversations to keep the peace. Over time, this leads to:

  • Persistent exhaustion and burnout from giving more than you receive

  • Growing resentment toward those you help, despite your best intentions

  • Disconnection from your own desires and authentic self

  • Relationships built on performance rather than genuine connection

  • Increased anxiety about disappointing others or facing rejection

  • Physical manifestations of stress, including sleep problems and tension

The frustration comes from knowing something feels wrong but being unable to break the pattern, as the fear of consequences feels too overwhelming.

How Therapy Helps

Therapy provides a pathway out of people-pleasing without sacrificing your genuine kindness. Through our work together, you'll:

  • Uncover the origins of your people-pleasing tendencies and what maintains them

  • Recognize that setting boundaries isn't selfish but essential for well-being

  • Develop practical skills for saying "no" without excessive guilt

  • Learn to differentiate between authentic generosity and fear-based compliance

  • Build confidence in expressing your needs directly

  • Create relationships based on mutual respect rather than one-sided giving

The goal isn't becoming uncaring or selfish—it's finding balance where you can be both kind and self-respecting, compassionate and confident.

Together, we'll:

  • Explore your unique history and how it shaped your "Nice Guy" tendencies

  • Identify specific triggers that activate your people-pleasing responses

  • Practice setting boundaries through role-playing and gradual real-world challenges

  • Develop personalized strategies to manage the anxiety that comes with saying "no"

  • Work through the fear of disappointing others or facing rejection

  • Celebrate your progress as you reclaim your authentic voice

My approach balances compassion with practical tools, helping you transform from constantly accommodating others to living authentically while maintaining genuine connections.

Therapist Mike Garrison, in a blue shirt seated on a sofa in a well-lit room, with a lamp and greenery in the background.

Ready to start feeling better?

Schedule a complimentary consultation with Mike Garrison today.